Please note
This is the speech as drafted and it may differ from the delivered version. 

Internationally qualified doctors and the changing context: culture, conduct and career prospects

GMC Chief Executive Charlie Massey's remarks at the British Association of Physicians of Indian Origin's 30th anniversary conference in Birmingham on Friday 20 November.

Good morning and thank you for the opportunity to be here today.

This is a big year for BAPIO as it celebrates its 30th anniversary.

In those three decades, the health landscape has changed dramatically.

But the initial aim with which BAPIO was founded, that of supporting international medical graduates, continues to be as relevant as ever.

Shape of the register

Internationally qualified doctors make a vital contribution to UK healthcare, with large numbers historically arriving year after year.

But our data show that things are changing.

The inflow of international talent, on which our system has relied, is now slowing. And the image of the UK as the destination of choice is increasingly outdated.

Our latest workforce data show a notable decline in the number of internationally qualified doctors joining the workforce, accelerating a trend that began in 2023.

At the same time, we’re seeing a contracting job market for internationally qualified doctors. Of those who passed PLAB and gained a licence in 2025, only 8% had made a revalidation connection – suggesting employment – within six months. That compares to 53% in 2021. Our research into the reasons why points to fierce competition for roles and a lack of relevant vacancies, as well as perceived demands for prior NHS experience.

This is having a knock-on effect on the number of internationally qualified doctors taking PLAB, the test needed to practise in the UK. Between 2023 and 2025 we saw a 40% drop in bookings for PLAB 1. And we’ve reduced the number of sites that offer the exam as a result.

UK prioritisation of training places and its impact

We also can’t overlook the impact of the new law around UK prioritisation for training places, which came into force this year. Analysis by the Nuffield Trust makes clear that this is already having a significant impact. This year, less than 2% of the doctors accepting a specialty training place were from what is now defined as the ‘non-priority’ group. This compares to around 28% last year.

Decisions about how to organise the medical workforce are the government’s alone. Our responsibility at the GMC is to ensure that those who join the medical register are qualified to do so, and that their practice meets the high standards rightly expected of them.

But we – like all bodies across the system – also have a responsibility to treat those who work in our health services with fairness and respect.

And a health system in which the doctors on whom we rely can see no future for themselves is damaging not only to them, but also to the system as a whole.

Internationally qualified doctors make up nearly 40% of the workforce. These are individuals who work at the frontline of patient care and whose skills are in global demand. They are also, by definition, a highly mobile group. If even a small proportion vote with their feet and leave UK practice, the impact could be significant.

So the stakes are high.

All doctors deserve to feel valued and supported in their workplaces. That matters to them personally, but also affects the quality of care they’re able to provide.

Time and time again, we’ve seen how poor culture has driven defensiveness, deterred individuals from speaking up, and led to a failure to engage openly with patients and colleagues. The Thirlwall Inquiry is but one recent example.

In the hierarchical, high-stakes field of healthcare, pernicious power dynamics and mutual mistrust can mean the difference between life and death. Because when teams don’t communicate well, or collaborate effectively, warning signs are missed, vital information slips through the cracks and avoidable harm can occur.

That’s why it’s so disturbing that over the last few years we have seen worrying signs of poor culture and increased bullying, harassment and discrimination.

In the discourse around the prioritisation of UK graduates for training places, we’ve seen some of that debate and discussion give way to hardening rhetoric and rising hostility. This has morphed into full blown bullying for many international graduates. This disgraceful behaviour is wholly unacceptable, and not in keeping with our – or the public’s – expectations of how a doctor should behave. And it will not be tolerated.

The SAS/LE experience

For doctors who qualified overseas, such shameful treatment can be especially harmful. We know these doctors are at particular risk of being isolated and overlooked, lacking support structures and navigating not just a new job but a new way of life.

These vulnerabilities can be further fuelled by the types of roles internationally qualified doctors find themselves in once in the UK.

In many cases, these doctors will end up in flexible roles, such as locally employed (LE) positions.

In recent years, we’ve seen significant growth in the number of doctors in LE roles, as well as those in specialty, associate specialist, specialist (SAS) posts, driven largely by international joiners.

These roles are crucial to the day-to-day delivery of patient care. And they offer a degree of flexibility that is valuable to many. But it’s also true that there are too many doctors in SAS and LE roles, which sit outside of training pathways, who feel overlooked and underappreciated. Without the structure of formal training, some SAS and LE doctors are denied the opportunity to develop and progress, leaving them feeling stuck in roles that don’t match their skills or ambition.

This is not only demoralising for the doctors affected. It is also a terrible waste of talent in a health system that can sorely afford to squander the resources at its disposal. That’s why we’re pushing for better recognition of and support for SAS and LE doctors, including through the expansion of alternative routes to progression.

This is a key part of Future Ed, our work to update the education framework. We’re currently in the insight-gathering phase of this programme, which will run until 2030.

We’re also highlighting the need for more flexible training pathways as part of the Medical Education and Training Review. Commissioned by NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care, the review is seeking to reform and modernise postgraduate medical training. We believe SAS and LE careers should be a key consideration within this.

It is not only structural barriers to progression holding those in SAS and LE roles back, but also their shoddy treatment in the workplace.

We recently published research which showed that almost one in four LE doctors and nearly one in three SAS doctors experienced or witnessed bullying or harassment in their role.

The survey found that internationally qualified doctors were more likely to report negative workplace experiences than their UK-qualified colleagues. And they were also less confident about challenging and reporting discrimination.

At a time when scandal after scandal has laid bare the poisonous effects of toxic culture, it is profoundly concerning that poor conduct continues to erode the trust and teamwork upon which good care depends.

Dismantling discrimination and disadvantage

The culture of a workplace is the result of the actions of the individuals within in – what people see, hear and do every day. But the way that workplace is experienced differs greatly depending on an individual’s role, position and identity.

For too many doctors today, those experiences are riddled with serial, systemic injustices, which badly affect their working lives.

That’s why we’ve made ED&I a strategic priority, committing to targets around unfairness in education and training and disproportionality in the referral of ethnic minority doctors to the GMC by employers.

We recently published an update on these targets, which showed encouraging progress around the issue of employer referrals. We’ve seen a 57% reduction in disproportionality in these referrals, compared to the 2016-20 baseline period. Crucial in this has been a more thoughtful approach to managing concerns at source, including more local resolution before concerns are escalated to us. Better induction has also been a significant factor. We’re proud of the role our Welcome to UK practice programme has played in this, alongside Welcoming and valuing IMGs, the standards we coproduced with NHS England and the BMA.

We’re also seeing an improving picture for internationally qualified doctors in terms of training environments. This includes an 18% narrowing of the attainment gap in specialty exams. While pass rates have risen for both internationally qualified doctors and UK graduates, they’ve risen more for the former, with a 9.1 percentage point increase. Internationally qualified doctors are also reporting more positive experiences in terms of the inclusivity of their learning environments.

This is not a ‘one and done’. Correcting decades-old, deep-rooted unfairness requires a concerted, long-term focus across a fragmented health system. Achieving meaningful change on entrenched issues requires a shared commitment and common purpose. That’s why we’re coordinating with fellow regulators on joint anti-racism principles to align efforts to root out inequality in UK healthcare.

At a local level, we’ll be amping up our efforts around what we know works, with a particular focus on mentoring and induction. We’ll also concentrate on improving understanding of culturally ‘safe’ environments, including through collaboration on the NHS England programme led by BAPIO’s own Professor Geeta Menon.

Conclusion

We know these programmes make a real difference to doctors on the ground, and we’re keen to roll them out as widely as we can.

But the reality is that more powerful than any of these interventions is the wider context and cultures in which they take place. All the training, mentoring and induction in the world is no match for a toxic culture that scapegoats or sidelines some within it.

Guarding against that pernicious pattern needs to be a system-wide and continuous effort.

It requires all us involved in medical education, training and practice to give culture the attention it deserves as a determinant of patient care.

But it also comes down to the actions of doctors, whose conduct – to both those they care for and those with whom they work – must be befitting of the trust placed in them by the patients we all serve.

Thank you.